History Telling: Filling in the Gaps
Saturday, September 29th, 2007It is often said that History is written and told by the conqueror to the detriment of those conquered. An article I came across posted by Dan Krieger, professor emeritus of history at Cal Poly, reminded me once again of Latinos’ missing history and the need to correct omissions by ensuring that our story is told-fairly and accurately.
In his posting, Krieger offered the following description of events at San Luis Obispo, California in the early 1850s when the leaders of the county addressed the education challenge of the day… What to do when 43% of student population does not speak English?
“English-born John Michael Price was the first American alcalde, the senior administrative officer for a district stretching along the El Camino Real from north of Santa Barbara to just south of San Jose. On March 9, 1850, Price directed the ayuntamiento, or town council, of San Luis Obispo to create a “school of primary letters.” … The first schoolmaster was Don Guillermo Searle. He was born in Chile to English parents. All lessons were in Spanish. There were no textbooks. Don Guillermo would read a passage from one of his own books. The children would repeat the passage phrase by phrase until they had it memorized. This rote method was used in schools throughout the world prior to the widespread use of the printing press. It is still used in developing countries…”
Several years later, in San Luis Obispo, this methodology evolved to a system that required students to translate their lessons from Spanish into English. Shortly thereafter, Mr. Newsom, a New Yorker, “improved on this system by giving lessons in English, and then compelling students to translate the material into Spanish, and then back into English”.
Nearly 100 years later, Orange County California found itself grappling still with the Spanish question…although this time in a very different manner. In March 1945, Gonzalo Mendez, William Guzman, Frank Palomino, Thomas Estrada, and Lorenzo Ramirez, a group of Latino parents in Orange County, Calif., sued four local school districts for segregating their children in “Mexican schools.” In February 1946, Judge McCormick issued his landmark decision and issued an injunction requiring Westminster to cease and desist segregation of Mexican children. Governor Earl Warren signed legislation prohibiting segregation in California schools in June 1947. This case, supported by LULAC, was also joined by NAACP, AJC and ACLU as friends of the court. Thurgood Marshall, who filed the amicus on behalf of NAACP, would years later use the findings in Mendez to argue Brown v Board of Education.
Yet, the history books used in our schools fail to include any reference to this major civil rights accomplishment. Nor do they mention the systemic tragedies that preceded the filing of this case.
On Sept 13, Justice Marshall’s son, Thurgood Marshall, Jr., member U.S. Postal Service Board of Governors, has taken a major step to correct this oversight as he announced the issuance of a US commemorative stamp to celebrate the 60th anniversary of the Mendez decision. I had the privilege of meeting Sylvia Mendez recently and learned how she is now dedicated to correct history books so that our children can learn their history, too. There is a whole movement to recapture Latino history while also raising funds to preserve the school and maintain the legacy.
As I listen to and read about the increasingly disturbing hostility directed towards Latinos in New Jersey and elsewhere, I truly hope that we-regardless of how tired and weary we may be or how much we already think we are doing-continue to uphold the principle that we are all created equal and not fall prey to ignorance. Those that do not know history are most certainly condemned to repeat it. I fear that unless we speak up and out, we will find ourselves exactly where our parents, and theirs, struggled so hard to change for the better. Let us make sure their struggles are recorded, respected and upheld. My grandmother always told me “Mas vale el Diablo por Viejo que por Diablo” - claro porque conoce su historia!